Karma Yoga and Renunciation: Freedom Through Enlightened Action
Bhagavad Gita Ch. 5 v. 1-5
True freedom is discovered not by withdrawing from life, but by learning how to act without attachment. When action is guided by wisdom and offered in service, it no longer binds—it liberates.
Contents
The Seeker’s Question Returns: Confusion on the Spiritual Path
Karma Yoga and Renunciation in the Bhagavad Gita: Two Paths Leading to One Freedom
The Eternal Renunciate: Freedom Beyond Desire and Aversion
Why Wisdom and Action Cannot Be Separated
One Realization, One Fruit: The Integrated Path of Yoga
PODCAST EPISODE: The Householder and the Monk - Choosing the Right Path
Freedom is not found by leaving life behind, but by learning how to live without attachment at the very heart of action.
The Bhagavad Gita returns again and again to the seeker’s essential question: How should I live the awakened life? In Chapter Five, this question arises once more—not as repetition, but as deepening insight. Here, the tension between renunciation and action is examined with clarity and compassion, revealing that true freedom does not depend on outer circumstances but on inner realization. Through the integration of wisdom and selfless action, the Gita points to a path where renunciation is lived—not by withdrawal from the world, but through enlightened participation in it. This teaching builds directly upon the previous chapter, in which the Bhagavad Gita reveals that action performed as sacrifice is purified through spiritual knowledge and no longer binds the soul.
The Seeker’s Question Returns: Confusion on the Spiritual Path
At the beginning of Chapter Five of the Bhagavad Gita, we once again encounter Arjuna’s confusion. This is not a failure on his part, nor a repetition without purpose. Rather, it reflects the unfolding journey of the seeking soul as it moves through successive levels of awareness. The same question arises again and again, but it is never asked from the same place in consciousness.
Arjuna wants to know: What should I do to live the spiritually awakened life? Krishna has already instructed him to stand up, to follow his dharma, and to act. Yet Arjuna asks again—not because he has forgotten, but because he is seeking clarity at a deeper level. He is asking, in essence, what is the most effective approach to enlightenment. Is there a faster way? Is there a clearer path?
This is a question familiar to every sincere seeker. We may find ourselves returning to the same dilemmas in life and wondering why they have not been resolved once and for all. Yet the Gita teaches us that spiritual questions recur because consciousness is evolving. Each return brings us closer to truth.
"The right path is not found by leaving life, but by learning how to live skillfully within it."
—Yogacharya Ellen Grace O'Brian
Karma Yoga and Renunciation in the Bhagavad Gita: Two Paths Leading to One Freedom
In the Bhagavad Gita, Chapter Five, verse 5.1, Arjuna voices his dilemma plainly:
You praise renunciation of actions,
and again you praise yoga, Krishna.
Which one is the better of these two?
Tell this to me definitely.
—Bhagavad Gita 5.1 , trans. Winthrop Sargent
He observes that Lord Krishna praises both renunciation of action and the yoga of action itself. He asks which of these two paths is truly better and requests a definitive answer.
This confusion arises at moments of difficulty. When life presents challenges, the mind often spins ideas of escape. We may wonder whether a monastic life should be easier, more peaceful, or free from struggle. When prayers seem unanswered, it is often because the mental field is not quiet enough to receive guidance.
Attachment to preferred outcomes and resistance to other possibilities create inner noise. When the mind is busy trying to get what it wants or avoid what it fears, guidance cannot come through. Clarity arises when the mind is calm, open, and unattached.
Arjuna’s question reflects an ancient and enduring tension: the perceived divide between the renunciate path and the householder path. One is associated with monks and ascetics who withdraw from worldly responsibilities in order to pursue wisdom without distraction. The other is the path of karma yoga—engaging fully in life while offering all action to the Divine.
To Arjuna, stepping away from the battlefield and retreating to an ashram may appear to be the quicker route to peace. This longing is understandable. When life becomes difficult, the grass often appears greener on the other side.
Yet the Gita reminds us that wherever we go, we take ourselves with us. External change does not, by itself, resolve inner conflict. Renunciation is not a matter of location, but of consciousness. True renunciation, as the Gita teaches, arises through wisdom that dissolves egoic doership rather than through avoidance of action.
The Eternal Renunciate: Freedom Beyond Desire and Aversion
In the Bhagavad Gita verse 5.2, Lord Krishna’s response begins with a powerful affirmation:
Both renunciation and the Yoga of action
Lead to incomparable bliss;
Of the two, however, the Yoga of action
Is superior to the renunciation of action.
—Bhagavad Gita 5.2, trans. Winthrop Sargent
There is no dismissal of either path. Both can bring liberation. However, Lord Krishna then makes a striking assertion. Of the two, the yoga of action is superior to the renunciation of action. This statement challenges deeply held assumptions about spiritual hierarchy. It affirms that awakening is not reserved for those who withdraw from the world.
The yoga of action, practiced with the right understanding, purifies the mind and leads to freedom. It allows spiritual realization to unfold in the midst of life itself.
In the next Bhagavad Gita verse 5.3, Lord Krishna redefines renunciation entirely:
One is to be known as the eternal sannyasi
Who neither hates nor desires,
Who is indifferent to the pairs of opposites, O. Arjuna.
That one is easily liberated from bondage.
—Bhagavad Gita 5.3, trans. Winthrop Sargent
The true renunciate—the eternal sannyasi—is not one who abandons action, but one who is free from hatred and desire, attraction and aversion.
Freedom is an inner condition. The key is motivation or intention. A renunciate, one who is free either in the monastery or in the world, is motivated by serving God, by living an enlightened life in harmony with the Truth. They do not have selfish motives. They are not fueled by desire for what they want or deterred by what they do not want.
For most of us, transformation takes time and discipline. It is an arduous path, not a freeway. It requires steadfast dedication. The path itself is clear when the goal is clear.
Why Wisdom and Action Cannot Be Separated
In the next Bhagavad Gita verse 5.4, Lord Krishna addresses the perceived difference between the paths of wisdom and action. Only the unwise declare them separate. When either path is practiced correctly, it yields the fruits of both.
“Samkhya and Yoga are different,”
The childish declare; not the wise.
Even with one of them, practiced correctly
One finds the fruit of both.
—Bhagavad Gita 5.4, trans. Winthrop Sargent
Through Samkhya practiced correctly (here meaning Jnana or wisdom yoga), one clearly discerns the truth of what they are as a spiritual being and what God or Life is. They are Self- and God-realized and act in the world free from the taint of ego-driven desire.
Through correctly practiced karma yoga, the mental field is purified, and the Self (divine Self) is revealed. Self- and God-realization brings freedom from selfish desire and liberation from ego-based identity.
Through discernment, one realizes the truth of the Self and acts free from egoic desire. Through karma yoga, the mind is purified, allowing Self-realization to dawn naturally. In both cases, liberation is the result.
One Realization, One Fruit: The Integrated Path of Yoga
In the Bhagavad Gita verse 5.5, Lord Krishna affirms that the realization attained by followers of wisdom is also attained by followers of yoga. The same state of freedom is available to both monks and householders.
The place that is attained by the followers of Samkhya (place meaning standing, position, or status)
It is also attained by the followers of Yoga.
Samkhya and Yoga are one.
One who perceives this, truly perceives.
—Bhagavad Gita 5.5, trans. Winthrop Sargent
This teaching dismantles spiritual hierarchy. Enlightenment is not dependent on role or lifestyle, but on readiness and sincerity. Each soul must walk the path appropriate to its dharma.
Kriya Yoga offers an integrated pathway for Self and God-realization, with essential tools of karma yoga and bhakti yoga to purify the heart and mind, and the power tool of jnana yoga (or Samkhya) for ultimate discernment, realization, and liberation.
Our lineage of teachers offers examples of enlightened yogis playing all the various roles—the cave dwelling avatar, Babaji, the enlightened householder Sri Lahiri Mahasaya, his disciple Sri Yukteswar who began his spiritual life as a householder and later became a swami, Paramahansa Yogananda who knew his dharma and destiny as a monk from an early age, and his disciple, my guruji, Roy Eugene Davis, who was a young monk, and later became an enlightened householder.
Monk or householder, it is the same Self. Same potential for enlightenment.
Which path is best? The one that is appropriate for you, in harmony with your dharma, your gifts, talents, work, and responsibilities. We might suspect that one reason Lord Krishna tells Arjuna, at this point in their conversation, that karma yoga is best is that it is best for Arjuna at that juncture.
For most people, the spiritual path is a progression of purification and integration of awareness at that new level. At first, Lord Krishna advises Arjuna to fulfill his dharma as a warrior, serving righteousness. But at the conclusion of the Gita, he tells him to “abandon all dharmas!” Confusing? No. See it as a progression.
There are two levels of right action:
1. Learning to see clearly what is dharmic, in harmony with higher purpose, what serves life, then aligning our thoughts, speech, and actions with that. This occurs when we begin the path and have a glimmer of light, faith to persevere with sadhana, and determination to succeed. We see our behavior in a new way because we begin to see life in a new way. We have a higher goal, a different motivation. We are now seeking enlightenment, liberation, and ultimate freedom.
2. Once the mind is purified and we are established in Self-knowing or Self-realization, right action is spontaneous. The method of course correction—notice, inquire, make a different choice, review, learn…. Is over. Action that is free of ego, or self-taint, will naturally be in harmony with the divine Self.
Let us take to heart Sri Lahiri Mahasaya's advice: Keep on keeping on. Behold, one day the goal!
Listen to the full podcast episode below.
Bhagavad Gita, pt 44: The Householder and the Monk - Choosing the Right Path
Chapter 5, v. 1-5
In this episode, we explore the opening verses of Bhagavad Gita Chapter Five, where the timeless tension between renunciation and action is resolved through wisdom. Rather than choosing withdrawal from life, the Gita reveals how freedom is found through selfless action offered without attachment. This teaching illuminates the path of karma yoga as a living renunciation—one that leads to peace, clarity, and spiritual awakening within everyday life.
Dive Deeper into Dharma Teachings and Practices
Drawing from the reservoir of Vedic wisdom and the principles of yoga, the Dharma 365! Live Your Higher Purpose online course outlines the path to a life of higher purpose. The course provide a comprehensive immersion in dharma studies and practices for discovering your higher purpose and living it every day with heart and meaning.
Stay Connected
Enter your email below to receive Illumination – inspirations, insights, and more from Yogacharya O’Brian to support you on your path of awakened living!
© 2025 Ellen Grace O’Brian